Jaguar V12 vs BMW V12

Sástu flottan BMW og vilt leyfa okkur hinum að njóta líka? Póstaðu því þá hér.

Jaguar V12 vs BMW V12

Postby zazou » Thu 10. Jan 2008 03:58

Ég skiptist á nokkrum bréfum við einn gaur á Jaguar spjallinu og fékk nærri óumbeðið til baka skemmtilega samantekt frá honum um hvernig hann upplifir muninn á þessum 2 bílum. Hann hafði áður skrifað mér að honum finndist Jaguarinn kraftmeiri og þegar ég rukkaði hann um skýringar fékk ég þetta til baka.

Hann á bæði 12 cyl Jaguar svipaðan mínum og svo 750iL sem reyndar er búið að breyta fyrir LPG (eitthvað alternatíft eldsneyti þarna í Stóra-Bretlandi).

Simon Crozier wrote:When i say more powerful i mean mid-gear etc you can feel the engine pulling harder in a drag race i think my money would still be on the BMW but you can tell its the gearbox making up the difference.

The BMW engine isnt stunningly more advanced that the Jag, its got bosch motoronic ECUs and it operates as two straight sixes :- so two dizzy, two maf two engines basically that just share a crank but neither of them even know that- right down to two fuel pumps. Then
there is a governor that sits above the two seperate ECUs and keeps them both in synch-ish. If you take the MAF off one side that bank shuts down and the other literally runs as a straight six with just a warning on the dash car will still toottle about till you get to the garage.

But bar the engine management there isn't alot you wouldn't recognize surprising really but just goes to show quite how advanced the Jag V12 actually was given it was designed 15 years earlier.

There is a noticeable down grade in performance when i swap to LPG becuase mine has an older style single point injection system (two point on for each maf but even they run separately after the heater) on LPG i'd reckon its down to about 240Bhp but some of thats also cos mine isnt calibrated properly at the min. But for the cost difference i just put the car gearbox in sport mode, set the cruise control - if its a short journey or i want the extra power i leave it on Petrol. Kinda like if the jag had a XJ6 <-> XJ12 button on the dash.

Jag is far and away a much, much nicer car but the BMW does have some interesting features that you wouldn't object to having on the jag...


Fyrsti pósturinn frá honum:
Simon Crozier wrote:For reference the 5.0 liter BMW v12 is rated at 300bhp exactly the same as the jag. Alot of people say the jag isnt really knocking out the claimed 300bhp but my Jag's engine certainly feels slightly more powerful than the BMWs - mine is a 85HE with the AJ6 TTExtractor exhaust, AJ6 SuperEnhanced ECU, larger air intakes, standard inlet manifold and throttle body (hoping to upgrade that this year) - didnt' have Cats in the first place so the engine certainly have comparible power rating and i've not seen/felt anything in the either engine that would suggest vastly different torque ratings. I had done the Jaguars modification before i got the BMW so never got a chance to compare to the stock jag.

The later 750i went up in power and engine displacement and i believe they stuck with the same ZF transmission for the early runs and later upgraded to different ZF so if you *could* get the engine and gearbox to talk then it certainly sounds like it could take the standard Jag V12 power and still be reliable (mine is 200,000mls in and doesnt appear to have been rebuilt).


Ég nenni ekki að fletta upp spekkum á E32 bílnum en Jaguarinn er 1835kg, 5,3l SOHC V12, 24v álvél sem skilar á bilinu 265-295hö. Togið er um 430Nm, þriggja þrepa skipting.
Nánar um það hér: http://www.hugi.is/bilar/articles.php?p ... Id=1375081
Brynjar
Alfa Romeo 159

Gamalt:
Jaguar XJ8
Daimler Double Six
Jaguar XJ12 Sovereign

Vísitölubílar eru SATANS
User avatar
zazou
Formúlubílstjóri
 
Posts: 2610
Joined: Sat 01. Nov 2003 13:43
Location: London

Postby Alpina » Thu 10. Jan 2008 07:21

hmmm... hefði haldið að M70 væri ,,öflugri vél

299 ps og 450 nm vs 280+ 430 nm
Sv.H

E30 CABRIO V12 M70B50 ///
ALPINA B10 BITURBO 346 @ 507
E34 550 V12 JML


(OO[][]OO)

http://alpina.123.is/pictures/
Sabine Schmitz wrote:"Fear disturbs your concentration."
User avatar
Alpina
Formúlubílstjóri
 
Posts: 33023
Joined: Tue 03. Sep 2002 18:17
Location: Ascari // Nürburgring

Postby zazou » Fri 11. Jan 2008 11:07

Alpina wrote:hmmm... hefði haldið að M70 væri ,,öflugri vél

299 ps og 450 nm vs 280+ 430 nm

Hefði haldið það líka.

Helv. er ekkert hægt að æsa hneturnar upp?

:twisted:
Brynjar
Alfa Romeo 159

Gamalt:
Jaguar XJ8
Daimler Double Six
Jaguar XJ12 Sovereign

Vísitölubílar eru SATANS
User avatar
zazou
Formúlubílstjóri
 
Posts: 2610
Joined: Sat 01. Nov 2003 13:43
Location: London

Postby Aron Fridrik » Fri 11. Jan 2008 11:39

kraftmeiri eður ei..



bmwinn fer þó í gang alla daga vikunar :tease:
BMW E34 ///M5
User avatar
Aron Fridrik
Formúlubílstjóri
 
Posts: 4778
Joined: Sun 04. Jun 2006 14:39

Postby Benzari » Fri 11. Jan 2008 13:05

aronisonfire wrote:kraftmeiri eður ei..



bmwinn fer þó í gang alla daga vikunar :tease:


:lol: ef þú kemst inní hann já.
1990 Benz 250D W124
Benzari
Formúlubílstjóri
 
Posts: 2674
Joined: Fri 25. Apr 2003 07:11
Location: Reykjavík

Postby gstuning » Fri 11. Jan 2008 13:18

Hann segir það sjálfur að honum finnst þetta vera í gírkassanum
sem er akkúrat það sem ég myndi halda sama.

Ef einhver nennir að pósta gríhlutföllunum þá ætti það að sjást.
líklega þrengra á milli gíra í Jaginum og vélin líklega ofar í bandinu þegar hann er að gefa í. fyrir utan að jagginn er með aðeins stærri vél, pínu minna hámarkstog enn líklega lengra powerband.
With great challenges comes great engineering.
Gunnar Reynisson
Image
User avatar
gstuning
Formúlubílstjóri
 
Posts: 15135
Joined: Sun 01. Sep 2002 22:50
Location: Spenge, DE

Postby zazou » Fri 11. Jan 2008 13:30

gstuning wrote:Hann segir það sjálfur að honum finnst þetta vera í gírkassanum
sem er akkúrat það sem ég myndi halda sama.

Ef einhver nennir að pósta gríhlutföllunum þá ætti það að sjást.
líklega þrengra á milli gíra í Jaginum og vélin líklega ofar í bandinu þegar hann er að gefa í. fyrir utan að jagginn er með aðeins stærri vél, pínu minna hámarkstog enn líklega lengra powerband.


Ratios:
4HP22 2.73 1.56 1.00 0.73 (BMW)
TH400 2.48 1.48 1.00 (Jaguar)
2.88 drif í Jaguar. Ég kann ekki að reikna :oops: en fyrsti er í ca 100, annar 160, þriðji rest.
Brynjar
Alfa Romeo 159

Gamalt:
Jaguar XJ8
Daimler Double Six
Jaguar XJ12 Sovereign

Vísitölubílar eru SATANS
User avatar
zazou
Formúlubílstjóri
 
Posts: 2610
Joined: Sat 01. Nov 2003 13:43
Location: London

Postby . » Fri 11. Jan 2008 16:35

þarf að græja nýja súrefnis skynjara, þá get ég hitt þig einhverstaðr og útkljáð málin
Bonjour 307 2005
BMW M-Zetor 2002
BMW 740 1996
Taxi 1972

BMW er reizing keppnistæki og bensar eru taxar
300.000 km eru nýju 200.000 km
User avatar
.
Getawaybílstjóri
 
Posts: 878
Joined: Tue 21. Jan 2003 13:43
Location: Reykjavík

Postby íbbi_ » Fri 11. Jan 2008 16:52

hverju sem tölum líður.. þá er annar

já nei..

ekkert :oops:
M.benz E320 Family Wagon
Chevrolet Silverado vinnujálkur
Chevrolet Silverado skúrajálkur
Cadillac eldorado 1973, ísbíll
User avatar
íbbi_
Formúlubílstjóri
 
Posts: 12484
Joined: Tue 27. May 2003 07:47


Return to Áhugaverðir bimmar

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 29 guests